This is your practical rubric to determine how you, as a candidate, perform in the Product Ideation round. Are you either a Strong Hire, Hire, Low-Confidence Hire, or No Hire.
1) Clarification & Scope: Ability to reduce ambiguity and restate the goal plainly.
2) Metrics & Goal Alignment: Choosing a meaningful north star plus secondary metrics that tie to the business goal.
3) Product Breadth: Generating a range of ideas (at least 7-8)
4) Product Depth: How well the top ideas are explained and whether they are creative and can move the metric.
5) Prioritization: After coming up with all these ideas, having the ability to prioritize the one with a clear framework. We like to use : Impact × Effort × Confidence to prioritize.
If you execute these 5 areas well, you’re likely to get a Strong Hire. Gaps in one or max 2 areas often move the decision to Hire or Low-Confidence Hire (i.e., requires coaching). Significant deficiencies across 3 areas typically lead to a No Hire.